두 차를 오랫동안 타면서 비교 시승 해보신 분이 과연 있을까 라는 생각이 우선 듭니다. 카맥스 같은 중고차 딜러쉽 같은데서 한번에 시승을 해보시면 좋겠네요. 그리고 딜러한테 사정을 이야기하고 진득하게 시승해보고 싶다고 말해보시면 더 좋겠구요 ^^ 게다가 승차감은 상당힐 주관적인 부분이라….

전 카니발 1 2, 그랜드 카니발을 쭈욱 몰고 타보고 하는데.. 3열(그/카는 끝까지 밀 수 있게 개조한 3열)이 제일 편안했습니다. ^^

글쎄 저는 오디세이 가지고 있는대 시에나는 몰아 본적이 없어서…
하지만 오디세이 핸들링은 밴 치고는 정말 좋다고 생각합니다.
이전에 몰던 차가 캠리였는대 오디세이나 캠리나 거의 비슷한 수준 아닌가 생각하는대요..
사실 오디세이 모는거나 세단 모는거나 별 큰차이 못 느끼겠습니다.
3째줄은 안타 봐서 모르고 둘째줄에 타봤는대 (와이프가 운전하면서) 전혀 불편함 못 느꼈습니다.)

여기가서 연구해 보시죠..
townhall-talk.edmunds.com/direct/view/.ef353cb

다시 생각해보니 오디세이 핸들링이 캠리보다 더 딱딱하다고 생각이 드네요.. 브레이크 느낌은 오디세이가 훨씬 좋다고 생각합니다.

핸들링이라고 해서 핸들 유격얘기 인줄 알고 들어왔는데 서스펜션 얘기네요.
3열은 어느차를 타도 다 승차감 별로 입니다. 운전대 잡는 사람이 3열 사람 생각해서 대통령리무진 몰듯이 하지 않는이상에는요.
그리고 기아차는 노면이 안좋을경우 덜컹거린다고 하지 물렁하다고 표현하지는 않지 않나요? 핸들링은 케러반이 아주 고속에서 아주 예민하더군요.
오디세이 > 시에나 > 세도나 순으로 보통 고르고 가격도 오디세이 순으로 높지요.

링크가기 귀찬은 분을 위해 퍼왔습니다.
핸들링에 관한한 시에나보다 오디세이가 훨씬 좋다고 써놨네요.
*********************************************
All,
After 8 years driving Sienna vans ( 2001 and 2004 LE model) I finally decided to have a change and go for a Honda Odyssey EX. Here are my comparisons.

FIRST: What I like About my 2004 Sienna 8 seater LE that is missing from my new 2009 Odyssey EX.

(1) The folding middle row seats that can tumble and secure in the up position in the Sienna.

On the Ody, I need to fully remove the middle row seats and store them in the garage to gain maximum utilization for loading large items like furniture. Just like the earlier generation Sienna.

The tumble forward action also makes it easier to load adult passengers in the third row in the Sienna. The Ody only slides forward and does not tumble forward for greater access to load goods from the side door.

(2) I miss the power sliding door button on the middle door column that is on the Sienna. I have to train myself to use the handle to open the door which I find less access able closing the door after loading the kids…

(3) I miss the temperature/compass/MPG readout by the rear view mirror on the Sienna.

(4) When installing 3 child seats in the middle row the Sienna seat configuration is more usable than the Ody.

On the Ody you cannot place a full size Child car seat (or even a booster seat) in the second row middle seat and expect to be able to adjust the forward and back position on the adjacent Window seats easily.

We decided to forgo the 2 row middle seat on the Ody and store it in the garage.

(5) I think the floor mats on the ODY is cumbersome with all the pieces and clips you have to contend with when time to clean. The Toyota is straight forward old school — take it out and wash…

To access the floor storage on the Ody is not easy because the floor mat is in the way…

(6) PET PEEVE: Categorized this under illogical…
I heard that this was standard Honda practise from long ago but why does Honda sell vans with roof rails but not include at least the cross bars to make them functional? They just add to wind resistance for owners who will not add the cross bars or other attachments to make them functional. You have to dish out an extra $200 for the bars ( $100 /a piece) to make the rails functional.

Toyota doesn’t fool around and adds full functionality of the roof rack when you buy an LE version….In my opinion well done Toyota.

(7) Minor —
I miss the ceiling radio console on the Sienna ( non DVD version). This allows me to add a aftermarket DVD system without having to cut the roof liner and route a DC power line. So after 3 years when I trade in the van I can remove the DVD player and put the car back the way it was.

*******
SECOND: Now what I ***LIKE*** about my new Honda Odyssey EX.

(1) The overall drive and ride experience.
When first drove a 2004 Sienna I thought the ride was superior to any van I have driven before and I thought this would be hard to beat.

Now when I drive my new Ody EX I can tell that it surpasses my 2004 LE driving experience. The suspension is just tuned right for comfort and the load of my family of 2 adults and 4 kids. I have not tried a full load yet to make a valued comment…

Engine even at 5 miles the Ody was very responsive and gear shifting is clean and smooth with no jerking movement. The 2004 Sienna I purchased had tranny issues since it was the first year of that new Sienna model and there was a noticeable accelleration lag and jerky shifting after a slowing down to come to a stop .

(2) Turning radius on the Ody is incredible compared to my 2004 Sienna. I would turn the wheel on the Ody expecting it to stop after a number of revolutions but it kept on going and I made very tight truns with ease. I found this such a plus…

(3) The stock sound system is superior on the Ody.

(4) The ability to adjust the air conditioning temp for the driver and front/rear passenger separately is a plus… Just needs getting used to…

(5) Not sure of the dimension difference but the Ody feels roomier inside. Even my 8 year old mentions that she can stand up straight in the Ody.

My Conclusion?
Honda should *pirate* the seating logic/design from Toyota Sienna . If they do so in my opinion Honda would be the hands down winner…

sounds like nothing will make you happy.
you better buy anything you want and then
install custom shocks.
nice custom shocks will make you happy.

FYI.
I have bilstein on my SUV.
it’s good shocks.

원글입니다. 많은 답글 감사드립니다. 눈치껏 시승을 감행해야겠네요. 사서 개조하는 것도 생각해봤는데, 세도나용 Shock은 시중에서 구하기 쉽지 않은 듯 합니다.

http://i.sohu.com/p/=v2=bQI2EzMxDTh0HMNtUy5jb20=/blog/view/194203153.htm
http://18337694.blog.hexun.com/
http://kaleen.sweetcircles.com/

http://column.iresearch.cn/u/atw3366/
http://column.iresearch.cn/u/atw3322/